Skip to content
Carbon Verification Limited home

Scope 3 verification

Make the evidence behind your value-chain emissions clearer.

We verify agreed Scope 3 categories by examining boundaries, calculation methods, assumptions and supporting information. A free readiness review helps your team identify concerns before the final audit.

Agree the coverage

Start with your inventory and reporting purpose.

The GHG Protocol defines 15 Scope 3 categories. Which are relevant, and which need verification, depends on your activities, reporting criteria and intended use. The coverage of the statement must be clear.

Purchased goods and services

Supplier information, activity data, spend-based methods and the treatment of gaps or estimates.

People and operations

Business travel, commuting, waste, fuel- and energy-related activities and other relevant categories.

Products and supply chains

Transport, capital goods, use and end-of-life of sold products, investments and other applicable value-chain sources.

What other organisations verify

Which Scope 3 categories are verified for CDP.

LRQA analysed the verification data organisations reported publicly through CDP in 2022. Among organisations that had Scope 3 emissions verified, this is how often each category was included.

Scope 3 categories covered by verification, as a share of organisations verifying Scope 3 in their 2022 CDP disclosures
GHG Protocol categoryShare of Scope 3 verifiers
6.Business travel
75.3%
1.Purchased goods and services
64.6%
3.Fuel- and energy-related activities
56.9%
5.Waste generated in operations
56.8%
7.Employee commuting
51.8%
4.Upstream transportation and distribution
50.5%
2.Capital goods
34.6%
9.Downstream transportation and distribution
30.5%
11.Use of sold products
29%
12.End-of-life treatment of sold products
21.7%
8.Upstream leased assets
16.7%
13.Downstream leased assets
15.2%
15.Investments
14.2%
10.Processing of sold products
10%
14.Franchises
7.4%

Source: CDP, The business benefits of third-party verification of environmental data (2023), p. 19, based on LRQA’s analysis of data reported publicly through CDP in 2022. CDP verification resources

Travel leads

Business travel is the category verified most often, by three in four Scope 3 verifiers. It is one of the easiest to calculate, which may explain why.

Purchased goods close behind

Purchased goods and services comes second, at almost two in three, but many companies still calculate it with spend-based factors. These are useful for benchmarking; actual supply chain data supports better decisions.

Downstream is rarely verified

Fewer than a third verify downstream transport or the use of sold products, and fewer than one in four end-of-life treatment. If these are material to your footprint, they deserve the same scrutiny.

We verify any of the 15 categories and agree in advance which are included, so the statement is clear about what it covers. The Scope 3 errors we find most often

Significance and exclusions

Do you have to include all 15 categories?

Not necessarily. ISO 14064-1 asks organisations to report their significant indirect emissions, and leaves the organisation to set its own criteria for what is significant: for example, the size of the emissions or your ability to manage them. The GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard takes a similar line: account for your Scope 3 emissions, and disclose and justify any exclusions.

Either way, the decision is yours to make, but it has to be reasoned, documented and applied consistently.

Criteria organisations commonly use

  • Size: categories above a set share of your total footprint
  • Influence: your ability to manage or reduce the emissions
  • Risk and opportunity: exposure to regulation, cost or supply chain change
  • Stakeholders: what customers, investors or CDP expect to see
  • Sector guidance: categories your sector is expected to report
  • Outsourcing: activities you used to carry out in-house

What we look for at verification

  1. Significance criteria that are written down and explained.
  2. A screening of all 15 categories, with an estimate of size even where data is limited.
  3. Each category included or excluded against those criteria, with the reason recorded.
  4. Exclusions disclosed in your report, with their estimated size.
  5. Difficulty getting data not used on its own to leave out a large category.
  6. The assessment reviewed each year, and whenever the business changes.

Methods and evidence

Estimates need a defensible basis.

Supplier data is not always complete. We examine whether the chosen methods, assumptions, emission factors and estimates are appropriate to the reporting criteria and supported by sufficient evidence. We assess the uncertainty and limitations.

Calculations

Trace the method and inputs, check conversions and assess consolidation.

Boundaries

Review relevant categories, exclusions and potential double counting.

Audit trail

Follow reported totals back to supporting records and the people responsible.

Free readiness review

Test the difficult areas while there is time to act.

  1. Agree the scope and fee

    We agree your reporting period, boundaries, the emissions to be covered, the assurance level and your deadline, then confirm the fee.

  2. Your free readiness review

    We review the information you already have, from part-year or last year’s data, and give your team private, documented findings with time to address them.

  3. Formal verification

    We verify the complete reporting period, an independent reviewer checks our work, and you receive your verification statement and findings report.

Discuss your Scope 3 information

A clear output

Know which data the conclusion covers.

The statement identifies the agreed reporting period, categories, criteria, assurance level and limitations. Findings provide a practical record of concerns for your organisation to address.

Avoided emissions are assessed separately from the organisational Scope 1–3 inventory; they should not be deducted from it.

Reporting criteria and verification

Start with a 20-minute conversation.

Tell us why you report, which scopes you need verified and when you need the statement. You do not need a finished inventory. We will explain how your free readiness review and verification would work.

No obligation